Rev. Isaac Dillon - 1849 to 1850
Rev. John Inskip - 1850 to 1851
Rev. John W. Weakley - 1851 to 1853
Rev. Wm. H. Sutherland - 1853 to 1854
Rev. M. Dustin - 1854 to 1856
Rev. John F. Marley - 1856 to 1858
Rev. Wm. I. Fee - 1858 to 1860
Rev. Allen T. Thompson - 1860 to 1862
Rev. Geo. W. Crum - 1862 to 1864
Rev. A. B. Wambaugh - 1864 to 1867
Rev. Geo. H. Dart - 1867 to 1868
Rev. Thomas Collett - 1868 to 1871
Rev. Lucien Clark - 1871 to 1874
Rev. Wm. H. Hypes - 1874 to 1875
Rev. S. B. Smith - 1875 to 1876
Rev. F. G. Mitchell - 1876 to 1879
Rev. T. J. Harris - 1879 to 1882
Rev. John F. Marlev - 1882 to 1885
Rev. R. H. Rust - 1885 to 1890
Rev. John R. Shannon - 1890 to 1891
Rev. A. H. Lucas - 1891 to 1895
Rev. J. A. Story - 1895 to 1905
Rev. E. P. Edmonds - 1905 to 1908
Rev. W. L. Y. Davis - 1908 to 1910
Rev. Walter D. Cole - 1910 to April 1915
Rev. E. P. Edmonds - April to Sept. 1915
Rev. E. S. Weaver - 1915 to 1919
Rev. Geo. W. Osmun - 1919 to Jan. 1926
Rev. E. H. Roberts - Feb. 1926 to 1929
Rev T Wallis Grose - 1929 to 1933
Rev. Harry E. Bright - 1933 to 1939
Rev. J. Carl Plummer - 1939 to 1946
Rev. Wm. Bashford Richards - 1946 to 1948
Rev. Ross Wilhide - 1948 to 1952
Rev. John W. McMahan - 1952 to 1957
Rev. Waldemar A. Haupt - 1957 to 1964
Rev. Leonard W. Mann - 1964 to 1969
Rev. Theodore W. Shoemaker - 1969 to 1975
Rev. Fred M. Mark - 1975 to 1980
Rev. C. Edwin Pellett - 1980 to 1986
Rev. E. James Dickey - 1986 to 1998
Rev. Donald Ramsey - 1998 to 2001
Rev. Lynn Huffman - 2001 to 2002
Rev. R. Stuart Rammes - 2002 to 2006
Rev. E. Cary Simonton - 2006 to 2010
Rev. Jeff Allen - 2010 to 2016
Rev. Steven Fewell - 2016-2019
Rev. Cynthia Atwater - 2019 to present
Rev. John Inskip - 1850 to 1851
Rev. John W. Weakley - 1851 to 1853
Rev. Wm. H. Sutherland - 1853 to 1854
Rev. M. Dustin - 1854 to 1856
Rev. John F. Marley - 1856 to 1858
Rev. Wm. I. Fee - 1858 to 1860
Rev. Allen T. Thompson - 1860 to 1862
Rev. Geo. W. Crum - 1862 to 1864
Rev. A. B. Wambaugh - 1864 to 1867
Rev. Geo. H. Dart - 1867 to 1868
Rev. Thomas Collett - 1868 to 1871
Rev. Lucien Clark - 1871 to 1874
Rev. Wm. H. Hypes - 1874 to 1875
Rev. S. B. Smith - 1875 to 1876
Rev. F. G. Mitchell - 1876 to 1879
Rev. T. J. Harris - 1879 to 1882
Rev. John F. Marlev - 1882 to 1885
Rev. R. H. Rust - 1885 to 1890
Rev. John R. Shannon - 1890 to 1891
Rev. A. H. Lucas - 1891 to 1895
Rev. J. A. Story - 1895 to 1905
Rev. E. P. Edmonds - 1905 to 1908
Rev. W. L. Y. Davis - 1908 to 1910
Rev. Walter D. Cole - 1910 to April 1915
Rev. E. P. Edmonds - April to Sept. 1915
Rev. E. S. Weaver - 1915 to 1919
Rev. Geo. W. Osmun - 1919 to Jan. 1926
Rev. E. H. Roberts - Feb. 1926 to 1929
Rev T Wallis Grose - 1929 to 1933
Rev. Harry E. Bright - 1933 to 1939
Rev. J. Carl Plummer - 1939 to 1946
Rev. Wm. Bashford Richards - 1946 to 1948
Rev. Ross Wilhide - 1948 to 1952
Rev. John W. McMahan - 1952 to 1957
Rev. Waldemar A. Haupt - 1957 to 1964
Rev. Leonard W. Mann - 1964 to 1969
Rev. Theodore W. Shoemaker - 1969 to 1975
Rev. Fred M. Mark - 1975 to 1980
Rev. C. Edwin Pellett - 1980 to 1986
Rev. E. James Dickey - 1986 to 1998
Rev. Donald Ramsey - 1998 to 2001
Rev. Lynn Huffman - 2001 to 2002
Rev. R. Stuart Rammes - 2002 to 2006
Rev. E. Cary Simonton - 2006 to 2010
Rev. Jeff Allen - 2010 to 2016
Rev. Steven Fewell - 2016-2019
Rev. Cynthia Atwater - 2019 to present